China Atheists Lured to U.S. Christian Schools
Haiying Wuâ€™s family in Shandong Province wasnâ€™t religious. After a born-again Texan teaching English in China advised her that Christian schools in the U.S. are safe and academically strong, she enrolled at Ben Lippen High School in Columbia, South Carolina.
Ben Lippen required her to attend church and chapel, take Bible class, and join a Bible study group. At first, she didnâ€™t understand â€œwhy you need to believe in something you canâ€™t view or touch,â€� she said. Gradually, it began to make sense. When the house parents in her dorm showed the 2004 film, â€œThe Passion of the Christ,â€� she wept. Shortly before her 2009 graduation, she was baptized.
Her parents were taken aback. â€œIn China, I donâ€™t think thereâ€™s any chance I would have become a Christian,â€� said Wu, 21, a junior at Tulane University in New Orleans. â€œIt takes a lot to convert someone. Because Ben Lippen is such a strong religious environment, it makes you feel you have to learn about Christianity, and how come everybody around you believes.â€�
As evangelical schools capitalize on the desire of affluent Chinese families for the prestige of an American education, many Chinese students are learning first-hand how the Bible Belt got its name.
While proselytizing is banned in China, Protestant -- and, to a lesser extent, Catholic -- high schools are doing their missionary work on this side of the Pacific Ocean. Through placement agents and religious networking, theyâ€™re recruiting growing numbers of students from China, most of them atheists, and encouraging them to convert, in the hope that some of them will spread the faith back home.
Plunged with little preparation into an intense religious environment, Chinese students often struggle to fit in. Some shed their skepticism and become Christians, delighting school officials and dismaying their families in China.
Eighty of Ben Lippenâ€™s 108 international students come from China, up from hardly any five years ago, said Emery Nickerson, director of the boarding program. A â€œlarge minorityâ€� commit to Christianity, he said.
â€œIâ€™m pleased that so many of these kids come to Christ while theyâ€™re here,â€� said Ben Lippen School Headmaster Mickey Bowdon. â€œIâ€™m not sure the Chinese government would be.â€�
Chinaâ€™s Ministry of Education and State Administration for Religious Affairs declined to respond to written questions.
â€œThe government is in a real quandary,â€� said Daniel Bays, director of the Asia Studies Program at Calvin College in Grand Rapids, Michigan, who researches Christianity in China. â€œThey canâ€™t forbid people from sending their kids overseas. They may worry about these kids coming back, but they canâ€™t do much about it. These kids are just added to the crop of suspects that they already have to deal with.â€�
Teachers, classmates and host parents with whom Chinese students stay are sometimes overly fervent in proselytizing them, said former Ben Lippen Headmaster David Edgren.
â€œWhat we have are wonderful, sensitive, caring, committed Christian people who want so much for this particular Chinese student to come to know the Lord Jesus Christ the way they do,â€� said Edgren, who now recruits Chinese students for Ben Lippen and other evangelical schools. â€œThere is sometimes a tendency for the Christian student/host family/teacher to press for and receive what appears to be a commitment.â€�
Non-believing Chinese parents choose Christian schools for their moral values, college placement records, and lower tuition than secular private schools, Edgren said. Because the U.S. is regarded in China as a Christian nation, many parents see Christian schools as part of mainstream American culture, said Susannah Clarke, who taught in China for three years and helps with a Bible study group at Ben Lippen.
Religious schools are the latest entrant in the race by American educational institutions to tap the lucrative China market. About 57,000 Chinese undergraduates, most paying full tuition, attended U.S. colleges in 2010-2011, six times as many as in 2005-06. A Chinese government affiliate has contributed millions of dollars to establish Confucius Institutes for Chinese language and culture on 75 American campuses.
Limited to one year of attendance at U.S. public secondary schools under federal law, Chinese students are flocking to private high schools, where they diversify student bodies and offset declines in domestic enrollment caused by the economic downturn.
The number of Chinese students at U.S. private high schools soared to 6,725 in 2010-11 from 65 in 2005-06, according to the U.S. Department of Homeland Security, which doesnâ€™t keep separate statistics for religious schools.
Beijing Recruiting Fair
Religious schools boost Chinese enrollment by sending staff members to China and using agents such as New Oriental Education & Technology Group Inc. (EDU), Chinaâ€™s largest education firm by market capitalization.
Known for preparing Chinese students for the SATs and other exams, New Oriental also connects them with U.S. high schools. Eight Protestant U.S. schools, including Ben Lippen, and two Catholic schools were represented at a New Oriental recruiting fair in Beijing in October.
One New Oriental business partner uses a religious appeal to open doors at Christian schools that arenâ€™t used to taking foreigners. Eduboston placed 119 Chinese students this year at 15 New England schools, including one Protestant and 12 Catholic institutions, said President Kason Park.
When school administrators balk because they donâ€™t have international advisers or English-as-a-second-language programs, Park tells them about a pastor in China who was jailed for handing out Bibles.
â€œSome people sacrifice so much to spread the gospel,â€� said Park, a Presbyterian. â€œNow we have people at our doorstep, offering money. I always tell the schools, â€˜God has a bigger plan than we see.â€™â€�
New Orientalâ€™s pipeline to religious schools worries Annalee Nissenholtz, a St. Louis-based counselor for international students and a consultant to the company.
â€œRelying on recruiters who do not emphasize their schoolsâ€™ religious focus, Chinese parents perceive these schools as â€™safeâ€™ and â€˜family-orientedâ€™ places where their children will get a typical American experience,â€� she said in an e-mail. â€œThey have no idea how religion permeates the day to day environment. I would no more place a Chinese student in an evangelical Christian school than in an orthodox Jewish school.â€�
The schoolsâ€™ religious emphasis, including teachers praying in class, has surprised some Chinese students, said Laura Chevalier, destinations program coordinator for the Association of Christian Schools International in Colorado Springs, Colorado.
â€œA Christian school is such a foreign concept coming out of China,â€� Chevalier said. â€œEven if theyâ€™ve been prepped a lot, until they get in that environment, they might not have any context to understand.â€�
Ben Lippenâ€™s application asks Chinese students what their understanding is of the Christian faith, who is Jesus Christ, and what it means to live in a Christian community. They also must agree to attend religious services, Bible study and Bible class.
â€œThey know, without a shadow of a doubt, they are coming to a Christian environment,â€� Bowdon said. â€œThey must be OK with that.â€�
Placement agents sometimes fill out the forms for applicants, Nickerson said.
â€œBefore students get here, there is always the question, â€˜Do the parents understand?â€™ he said. â€œThey arenâ€™t sending kids here to learn about who Jesus Christ is. We do our best to publicize our mission.â€�
Influx of Non-Christians
Some religious schools have adapted their missions to fit the influx of non-Christians.
Students from South Korea, which has a higher percentage of Christians than China, previously dominated international enrollment at Ben Lippen and other religious schools.
As the Chinese replaced the Koreans, Ben Lippenâ€™s trustees wrestled with the question of whether to require boarding students to be Christians, said Kelly Pengelly, former director of the boarding program. In October 2010, they decided that a majority didnâ€™t have to be Christian, she said.
Whitinsville Christian School in Massachusetts, which requires applicants to submit recommendations from pastors, waived the rule earlier this year for Chinese students, said Roann Karns, international student coordinator.
Administrators at Whitinsville, which has seven Chinese students, â€œembraced the idea of being able to expose them to Christianity,â€� she said.
Reconciling the Mission
While its mission statement says its purpose is â€œto serve as partners with Christian parents,â€� Southside Christian School in Simpsonville, South Carolina, recruited six Chinese students from non-Christian families last year and is increasing Chinese enrollment to 12 next month, said Stephen Reel, superintendent.
The school reconciles recruiting Chinese students with its mission by housing them with Christian families, he said. Several have â€œmade some level of statement of faith,â€� he said.
Wheaton Academy, an evangelical school in West Chicago, Illinois, started an introductory Bible class last year for non- Christian international students, said Chief Operating Officer Jon Keith. Of its 37 international students, 22 come from China, he said.
Wheaton also plans to supply hundreds of international students a year, of whom between half and two-thirds would come from China, to 22 Christian schools nationwide, Keith said. Participating schools will pay Wheaton for membership in the network plus â€œa modest per-student placement fee,â€� Keith said.
St. Maryâ€™s Preparatory, a Catholic boysâ€™ school in Orchard Lake, Michigan, where 50 of 65 international students come from China, plans a â€œscaled-downâ€� introductory catechism class for non-Catholics next year, said James Glowacki, headmaster.
Chinese students pay $41,750 a year for tuition and room and board, $15,000 more than boarders from the U.S., reflecting expenses such as advertising, international admissions staff, and English as a second language, he said.
While some trustees were leery of bringing so many non- Catholics to St. Maryâ€™s, they couldnâ€™t pass up the chance to evangelize. One trustee said, according to Glowacki, â€œWe have blank slates coming that we have an opportunity to write upon.â€�
Communists Expelled Missionaries
Converting the Chinese isnâ€™t easy in their native country, even as Christianity is growing there. Between 80 million and 125 million Chinese -- out of a population of 1.33 billion -- are Christians, including about 12 million Catholics, said David Aikman, a former Time Magazine foreign correspondent and author of the book, â€œJesus in Beijing: How Christianity Is Transforming China And Changing the Global Balance of Power.â€�
Most Protestants worship at illegal â€œhouseâ€� churches, which are sometimes tolerated by the regime, rather than the government-controlled Three Self Church, Aikman said.
Communists took control of China in 1949 and expelled foreign missionaries. Forbidden from evangelizing, American Christians who teach English or work in social service agencies in China spread the word discreetly.
â€œWe made a pledge to local officials that we would not do overt faith-based teaching in our classrooms, and we honored that,â€� said Nathan Musgrave, assistant pastor at Heartland Evangelical Free Church in Central City, Nebraska, who taught English from 2004 to 2008 to young adults in China, primarily farm and factory workers. â€œThere was a lot of informal contact outside the classroom. Students would visit our homes, and issues of faith would come up naturally. We would share openly at that time, but not unless the student broached the subject.â€�
â€˜Prays With Teammatesâ€™
When Randy Liang wanted to study in the U.S., his parentsâ€™ friends at a Christian group that provides medical and small business services in Shanxi Province recommended Ben Lippen. He enrolled in January, 2010, as a sophomore, largely unfamiliar with the Scriptures and the English language.
He â€œreally hatedâ€� the school at first, he said. â€œI thought they were trying to force me to be Christian. I couldnâ€™t understand what theyâ€™re talking about. I thought, â€˜This is boring.â€™â€�
Liang adjusted as his English improved and he joined teams in four sports: football, wrestling, cross-country and track. After watching a creationist video in Bible class, he developed doubts about evolution. Now a senior, he prays with teammates before games, he said. He lives in a teammateâ€™s home, and prays with the family for success on exams.
Still, Liang plans to postpone any religious commitment and concentrate on schoolwork until heâ€™s had more experience, he said. While those around him encourage him to become Christian, â€œI control my own brain,â€� he said.
In a Ben Lippen classroom on a Sunday evening in early December, the discussion and the Bibles are in Mandarin. With Christmas approaching, a volunteer from the Chinese Christian Church of Columbia is teaching the nativity story to 20 Chinese teenage boys fulfilling their Bible Study requirement.
Some students send text messages, or doze. Asked what Christmas means, one responds, in a joking allusion to a similarly-pronounced Chinese-language character, â€œEgg.â€�
â€œTheyâ€™re bored,â€� said the leader, Thomas Su, 35. â€œThey come from an atheist background. They donâ€™t think itâ€™s the truth. They think, â€˜Why do I waste my time?â€™ They were mocking me.â€�
â€œA lot of them are anti-Christian. They know weâ€™d like them to become Christian,â€� said Susannah Clarke, who was instructing a girlsâ€™ group across the hall. â€œItâ€™s been drummed into them: thereâ€™s no God, the government is great. They know if they go back as a Christian, their parents will not be happy.â€�
Bridging the linguistic, religious and cultural gap between Chinese and American students is a challenge at Ben Lippen. Named for a Scottish phrase meaning â€œmountain of trust,â€� it stands on the hilltop campus of Columbia International University, overlooking the Broad River.
Ben Lippen has 392 students in grades 9-12. Day students, who must have at least one parent active in an evangelical church, make up almost three-fourths of the enrollment. Few of the 80 Chinese students come from Christian families, Nickerson said.
Twenty Chinese students stay with local evangelical families, such as Rick and Jennifer Byers. The school is paying them $3,200 a month this year to host four Chinese students.
â€œWe donâ€™t do this for the money,â€� said Jennifer Byers. â€œWe do this because we want to win these kids to Jesus Christ. If thatâ€™s what eternity is all about, thatâ€™s the most important thing we can do.â€�
â€˜No Touchâ€™ Policy
The Chinese pay about $30,000 a year for tuition and room and board, plus $930 to $2,270 for English as a second language. Tuition for day students is about $11,000.
The school has a strict behavioral code. Any student who â€œprofesses to be homosexual/bisexualâ€� or â€œsupports or otherwise promotes such practicesâ€� may be expelled, the school handbook states. â€œTo avoid temptation, we enforce a â€˜no touchâ€™ policy between the sexes at all times,â€� the handbook states.
For students who voluntarily confess and repent involvement in â€œsexual immorality, or use of alcohol or illegal drugs, the opportunity for reconciliation is available,â€� with lesser consequences such as suspension or drug testing, it says.
Chinese students often arrive at Ben Lippen with less English than their entrance exam scores predicted.
â€œThereâ€™s a lot of dishonesty or padding,â€� Nickerson said. Even if they are qualified to be high school juniors in China, they may spend a year or two as freshmen taking English-as-a- second-language courses until they become fluent enough to handle a regular load, Nickerson said. While taking Bible class in English, they worship at the Chinese church and participate in evening Bible study in Mandarin.
Boarders must speak English in common areas of their dormitories. â€œThank you for speaking English onlyâ€� reads a sign in one house, where 11 of 14 residents come from China. Rule-breakers may lose their computers for a few hours, said Houseparent Marty Gilpatrick.
Like other Ben Lippen courses, English-as-a-second language instruction is steeped in Scriptures. Randy Headley, a former Ben Lippen history teacher, diverged from this approach last year when he taught ESL to newcomers from China.
While he used one Christian text, Johann Sebastian Bachâ€™s church cantatas, he â€œtried to not push religion too hard,â€� and emphasized vocabulary such as the names of countries and vegetables, he said.
The Chinese â€œneed a rest somewhere in the institution,â€� Headley said. â€œI gave them a rest. They appreciated it. Some Americans didnâ€™t. Perhaps many ESL teachers thought it was their one chance to save people.â€�
Chinese students enhance diversity of evangelical schools not only ethnically but also intellectually. When Ben Lippen teacher Tom Pengelly asked his comparative-government class whether God is sovereign over national leaders, a Chinese student responded, â€œNo. If the Lord was sovereign, why would He allow Hitler, Mao, and George W. Bush.â€�
Conservative Southerners in the class were scandalized by the pairing of Bush with two tyrants, Pengelly said. â€œOne football player said, â€˜You canâ€™t say that!â€™â€�
Founded in 1940, Ben Lippen in its early decades housed and educated children of American missionaries. As missionaries began taking their children abroad, the school sought foreign students to replace them.
â€œOriginally, we brought children of missionaries here,â€� Headmaster Bowdon said. â€œNow weâ€™re preparing future missionaries. Theyâ€™ll go back to their own country, with the claims of Christ and a transformed heart.â€�
Recruiting in China
David Edgren, who had taught English at a Chinese university, became headmaster in 1992. Three years later, he went to China and brought back 15 students.
â€œThat was a very incredible thing from our schoolâ€™s standpoint,â€� he said. â€œFrom that point on, I recruited in Korea and would go back and forth to China.â€�
One of those students, Henry Guo, drowned in a lake during a party celebrating the end of the 1995-96 school year. In the woods, near the Chinese studentsâ€™ dormitories, a plaque memorializes him.
Guo converted at school, said Southside Christianâ€™s Reel, then a Ben Lippen administrator.
â€œWe had the assurance in our hearts that he had given his life to Christ and would have eternal salvation as a result,â€� he said. â€œThat was the silver lining.â€�
Ben Lippenâ€™s Chinese population was dwindling by the time Edgren left in 2000 to become headmaster at Nebraska Christian School in Central City, Nebraska, where he also initiated Asian recruiting. By 2006, â€œthere were zero Chinese studentsâ€� at Ben Lippen, said then-Headmaster Brian Modarelli. Eager to fill beds, Modarelli turned to Edgren.
The 69-year-old Edgren now represents nine schools, six of them Christian. For each Chinese student he places, Ben Lippen pays him 15 percent of the $30,000 first-year tuition and room and board, 10 percent of the next yearâ€™s payment, and 5 percent for the third and fourth years, Nickerson said. Depending on the school, his first-year commissions range from zero to 15 percent, and he splits the fees with agencies in China that find the students, Edgren said.
Multi-year payments motivate agents to encourage Chinese students to stay at Ben Lippen, Nickerson said.
â€œAt some point, the student is going to be angry with us,â€� he said. â€œIf they just run to the agent and leave, the student hasnâ€™t learned, and we lose financially.â€�
High School Tour
New Oriental, based in Beijing, supplies some of the students whom Edgren places, he said. Edgren began working with New Oriental in 2010, and took two company officials to visit 15 U.S. high schools, most of them Christian.
He and several evangelical school administrators, including Southsideâ€™s Reel, had lunch with New Oriental executives at a premier Beijing restaurant before a 2010 recruiting fair sponsored by the company, Edgren said.
New Oriental doesnâ€™t have a religious agenda, and funnels students to Protestant and Catholic schools because of market demand and relationships with agents such as Park and Edgren, they said. New Oriental recently started a separate department for U.S. secondary schools, Park said.
â€œNew Oriental does not promote religion of any denomination,â€� President Louis Hsieh said in an e-mail. â€œIt is the familiesâ€™ decision if they want their kids to attend a Christian or non-Christian high school or college.â€�
Meeting Yao Ming
At the New Oriental fair this past October, high school representatives interviewed students and gave presentations. Northland Christian School in Houston provided students with a package of gifts, including a key chain, notepad and pen.
Kevin Roberts, chairman of Northlandâ€™s board, impressed students by telling them that he had met Yao Ming, the retired Chinese star of the National Basketball Associationâ€™s Houston Rockets, in the teamâ€™s locker room and been given one of Yaoâ€™s high-top shoes as a memento.
â€œObviously, when you put a slide up there of Yao Ming, thatâ€™s a good recruiting tool,â€� said Headmaster Daniel Woods.
Guan Yuntian, a 15-year-old from Beijing, was interviewed by three schools, including Northland.
â€œReligious school is fine for me,â€� she said. â€œThe school will be better disciplined than other schools,â€� and the tuition lower. â€œItâ€™s not bad to have a religion as it may help me to be stronger.â€�
Zhang Shaoxuan, the father of another girl at the fair, would gladly send her to a Christian school, he said.
â€œBoth religious school and private schools are fine, the public schools are what you donâ€™t want to be in,â€� he said. â€œBecause there will be all kinds of odd students there.â€�
His experience with Chinese culture has taught Edgren that many Chinese students at Christian schools convert to please administrators or save face, he said.
Of Ben Lippenâ€™s 80 Chinese students, â€œif there are more than three, four, five believers as I would understand a commitment to Jesus Christ, Iâ€™d be surprised,â€� he said. â€œFrom a practical standpoint, we donâ€™t know until the kid goes back to China. Many of them will not tell their parents.â€�
Chang Su was unusually blunt. A Shenzhen native, whose father is a computer engineer and whose mother teaches kindergarten, she â€œdidnâ€™t want anything to do with a Christian school,â€� she said.
She opted for Ben Lippen after missing the application deadline for secular private schools. Meeting Edgren, she informed him that she was not Christian, she said.
She was â€œso antagonistic,â€� said Edgren. He thanked her for her honesty and told her she would have to go to church.
Late for Church
Entering Ben Lippen as a junior in 2008, Su clashed with dormitory parents over the requirement to turn in her computer and cell phone at night. When she was late for church one Sunday, they and the other girls left without her; she took a taxi. Accusing her of lying and disrespect, school officials sent her to a Christian counselor, she said.
â€œIt was a really hard time,â€� she said. â€œI didnâ€™t feel loved at all. I cried a lot.â€�
Her teachers stood by her. â€œI could feel the love from them,â€� she said. â€œThere was no reason for them to love me. They were willing to forgive me.â€�
The more she read the Bible, the more truth she discovered there. After praying for a month, she felt the Holy Spirit one night in March 2009.
â€œBefore, what I believed, what Chinese people believe, is that people are innately good,â€� she said. â€œI realized that I was sinful. I was lying, not loving. Those are as bad as killing someone. Thereâ€™s no difference between me and a murderer.â€�
She was baptized in April, 2009. Now a sophomore at Davidson College in North Carolina, Su proselytized vacationers this past summer on Myrtle Beach. She tells her parents and grandparents about Jesus. â€œThey havenâ€™t converted yet, but theyâ€™re open to it,â€� she said.
She hopes to become a neurosurgeon and return to China. â€œGod wants me to go back to China,â€� she said. â€œSomeday if Jesus calls me, I will be a missionary there.â€�