Originally posted by marcteng:
given that in his first season he won the CL and reached the league cup final, its not that bad.
as for epl (bread & butter), i think rafa needs at least a few more seasons to even challenge chelsea 4 the title. when chelsea keeps buying n buying every players every season, all are fighting for runner-up, third and fourth place to play for CL and hope to win some cup, be it fa cup or CL or league cup.
to reach the old liverpool heights in the 70's and 80's, you need a few more of gerrard type of players in the squad, like the 80's barnes, rush, beardsley, nicol, hansen, mahon etc. after all, good players make the team great.
to be successful again, rafa needs to buy correctly and cannot afford to invest in new players and the player didnt live up to expectations as money is tight, unlike chelsea. rafa also needs to build up the youth system from scratch. if there are 3 or 4 good players coming from the ranks in a few years time, that would save money otherwise spent on buying players. he would be advise to start looking for boys in asia, africa, brazil (samba boys)and argentina, holland also.
I agree that he needs time and the right players for the EPL.
Not sure about the players your mentioned though.
Only selective few asians are probably good enough for the EPL and most of them have been snapped up. It's going to be a gamble taking in African players. We've seen many African flops at Liverpool over the past 5 years, Rigobert Song, Salif Diao, Diouf. Of course there are the good ones like Titi Camara.But still, Im not so sure. Brazillian players will inject natural flair and flamboyance. But then again, a big gamble as to whether they can adjust to the English way of play. Work permit issues could become a deterrent factor. Same for Argentinians.
I guess the best kind of players are the proven ones at EPL level. Sometimes, you don't have to look far. Think along the likes of Scott Parker,Stewart Downing,Kevin Davies, Steed Malbranque.