Problematic trains

• Bus and Train LoVuR

  1 May 10, 19:15

  (RECOMPILING LIST)

  Trains with faulty motor sound                                                                                  

  C151
  025/026 (Car 2025)
  035/036 (Car 2035)
  039/040
  041/042 (Car 1041 , 2041)
  045/046 (Car 2045)
  047/048 (Car 1047)
  057/058 (Car 1058)
  071/072
  079/080 (Car 2080)
  091/092 (Car 3092)
  093/094 (Car 1093)
  103/104 (Car 1104)
  117/118 (Car 1117)
  
  C751B
  339/340 (Car 3340 , 1340 , 2340)

  Trains with flat wheel(s)

  C151
  003/004 (Car 1003)
  005/006 (Car 2006)
  009/010 (Car 1009 , 2010)
  013/014 (Car 1013)
  015/016 (Car 2015)
  017/018 (Car 1017 , 3017)
  019/020 (Car 2019)
  021/022 (Car 1022)
  023/024 (Car 3024)
  027/028 (Car 1027, 2027, 2028)
  033/034 (Car 1034)
  035/036 (Car 1036 , 2036)
  037/038 (Car 3038)
  041/042
  045/046 (Car 2045)
  047/048 (Car 1048 , 3048)
  049/050 (Car 1050 , 2050)
  051/052 (Car 1051)
  053/054 (Car 2053)
  055/056 (Car 2056 , 1056 , 3056)
  057/058 (Car 3058 , 1058, 2057)
  061/062 (Car 1061, 1062 , 2062)
  063/064 (Car 1064)
  069/070 (Car 3069 , 1070)
  071/072 (Car 1072 , 1071)
  073/074 (Car 1074)
  075/076 (Car 3075 & 2076)
  077/078 (Car 3078 , 1078 & 2078)
  079/080 (Car 2079 , 1079 , 1080)
  081/082
  085/086 (Car 3085)
  089/090 (Car 2090)
  091/092 (Car 1091 , 2091)
  095/096 (Car 1095)
  099/100 (Car 2099)
  101/102 (Car 2101, 3101)
  105/106 (Car 1106)
  111/112 (Car 1111 , 2111)
  113/114 (Car 1113)
  115/116 (Car 1115 , 2115 , 3115 , 2116)
  117/118 (Car 1117)
  119/120 (Car 1120)
  121/122 (Car 1122 , 3122)
  129/130 (Car 3130 , 2130)

  C651
  213/214 (Car 2214 , 1214 , 3214)
  223/224 (Car 1224, 3224)
  227/228 (Car 2227)
  235/236 (Car 3235)
  237/238 (Car 1237)

  C751B
  315/316 (Car 1315 , 2315)
  317/318 (Car 3317)
  319/320 (Car 2320 , 1320 , 3320)
  321/322 (Car 1322)
  329/330 (Car 3329 , 2330)
  331/332
  333/334 (Car 3333)
  335/336 (Car 2336 , 2335)
  337/338 (Car 2338 , 3337)
  339/340 (Car 1339 , 2340)
  341/342 (Car 1342 , 3341)
  345/346 (Car 3346)
  347/348 (Car 1347 , 2347)
  349/350 (Car 2349 , 2350)
  351/352 (Car 2351)

  Trains with ATO problem (Braking)

  C151
  011/012
  043/044
  053/054
  095/096
  105/106

  Trains with STARIS error(s) (C151 only)
  007/008
  009/010
  011/012
  013/014
  015/016
  021/022
  025/026
  041/042
  043/044
  045/046
  051/052
  059/060
  069/070
  075/076
  077/078
  081/082
  083/084
  089/090
  095/096
  103/104
  105/106
  107/108
  109/110
  111/112
  113/114
  117/118
  119/120
  125/126

• Kawac151

  2 May 10, 18:46

  015/016's flat wheels sonuded a tat too loud Car 2015

• Kawac151

  4 May 10, 15:56

  Ad on 045/046 was . (sorry for being a little OT). But ride in there was

• Din89

  6 May 10, 13:05

  Just now,i board 1063(c151) from eunos to jur..the car jerk up & down when accelerating/moving..Damn scary man..Is this b'cos of flat wheels??

• Bus and Train LoVuR

  6 May 10, 17:24

  Originally posted by Din89:

  Just now,i board 1063(c151) from eunos to jur..the car jerk up & down when accelerating/moving..Damn scary man..Is this b'cos of flat wheels??

  Suspension problem.

• smrt3099

  6 May 10, 17:26

  Originally posted by Din89:

  Just now,i board 1063(c151) from eunos to jur..the car jerk up & down when accelerating/moving..Damn scary man..Is this b'cos of flat wheels??

  This can be a headache

• Samuel Lee

  6 May 10, 18:19

  Originally posted by Bus and Train LoVuR:

  Suspension problem.

  Huh? If there is no guide rails installed, will that = easy or sure derail?

• wenjie639

  6 May 10, 18:49

  Originally posted by Samuel Lee:

  Huh? If there is no guide rails installed, will that = easy or sure derail?

  It would not derail, the wheels will be still on the tracks, just that the suspension failed

• Bus and Train LoVuR

  6 May 10, 18:50

  Originally posted by Samuel Lee:

  Huh? If there is no guide rails installed, will that = easy or sure derail?

  It is the train's problem , not the guide rails problem. Anyway , straight tracks/not sharp curves wouldn't derail?

• willis_chong

  6 May 10, 18:52

  Originally posted by Din89:

  Just now,i board 1063(c151) from eunos to jur..the car jerk up & down when accelerating/moving..Damn scary man..Is this b'cos of flat wheels??

  On 18th March 2010, I filed a complain about this to SMRT.

  On 29th April 2010, they replied.

  Dear Mr Willis Chong
  
  Thank you for your feedback regarding train 1063 carriage suspension problem.
  
  We have rectified the fault.
  
  Thank you once again, for informing us.
  
  Yours sincerely
  Ang Siew Tee (Ms)
  Senior Officer,Customer Relations
  Corporate Marketing and Communications
  SMRT Corporation Ltd

  So apparently...

• Bus and Train LoVuR

  6 May 10, 18:54

  Originally posted by willis_chong:

  On 18th March 2010, I filed a complain about this to SMRT.

  On 29th April 2010, they replied.

  So apparently...

  Until today , they still did not rectified the problem.

• youyuan

  6 May 10, 20:06

  001-002 (2002) air-con making faulty noise.

• smrt3099

  6 May 10, 20:49

  097/098 aircon also very noisy

• ObsessionStaris

  6 May 10, 21:39

  Haha. Should complain that there is alot of STARIS fault in C151 trains. wil cause confusion de ...

• Kawac151

  7 May 10, 10:45

  Originally posted by Din89:

  Just now,i board 1063(c151) from eunos to jur..the car jerk up & down when accelerating/moving..Damn scary man..Is this b'cos of flat wheels??

  Yeah. the last i sat it it was super bumpy.

• smrt3099

  7 May 10, 11:10

  043/044 also causing alot of bumpy rides

• smrt3099

  10 May 10, 21:13

  2099 has its wheels flat

• smrt3099

  10 May 10, 21:19

  011/012 will cause weird motor sound when its moving

• Kawac151

  11 May 10, 12:38

  2062 have flat wheels

• Bus and Train LoVuR

  11 May 10, 18:24

  Originally posted by smrt3099:

  011/012 will cause weird motor sound when its moving

  Carriage number please.

• Bus and Train LoVuR

  14 May 10, 09:13

  Add : Car 1034 , Car 1237 to flat wheels
  Remove : 209/210 from flat wheels.

• Operation//Overkill

  15 May 10, 01:20

  STARIS very easy tio glitch.......

• Dragonaxe

  15 May 10, 16:32

  Car 2053 keep on moving up and down, from outside, the couplers from 1053/2053 vibrate like mad. Suspension problem isit?

• Dragonaxe

  15 May 10, 16:33

  Originally posted by ObsessionStaris:

  Haha. Should complain that there is alot of STARIS fault in C151 trains. wil cause confusion de ...

  Lol, if 1 ppl complain right, SMRT don't care. Must alot ppl complain then they take action

• Apalis56

  15 May 10, 16:41

  Originally posted by Operation//Overkill:

  STARIS very easy tio glitch.......

  But why is it that Hong Kong's MTR teh 'STARIS' (ok, I dunno the name) never got so many glitches like our MRT? Hmph.. must be something.